WASHINGTON – A coalition of 20 state attorneys common filed a lawsuit Monday difficult the Trump administration’s demand that their states flip over private knowledge of individuals enrolled in a federally funded meals help program, fearing the data can be used to assist mass deportations.
The information demand comes because the Trump administration has sought to gather non-public data on principally lower-income individuals who could also be within the nation illegally. It has already ordered the Inner Income Service and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to share non-public data with the Division of Homeland Safety to assist in deportation efforts.
The U.S. Division of Agriculture told states final week that it had till Wednesday at hand over the info for these enrolled in its Supplemental Vitamin Help Program, or SNAP, which serves greater than 42 million individuals nationwide. The USDA mentioned the info will assist it fight waste, fraud and abuse.
The states’ lawsuit seeks an injunction to dam the info switch. Within the meantime, state attorneys common within the SNAP lawsuit mentioned they won’t disclose what they contemplate to be non-public data of recipients — together with their immigration standing, birthdates and residential addresses — as a result of they consider it might be a violation of privateness legal guidelines.
“It’s a bait-and-switch of the worst sort,” California Lawyer Basic Rob Bonta mentioned in a Monday afternoon information convention saying the lawsuit. “SNAP recipients offered this data to get assist feeding their households, to not be entered right into a authorities surveillance database or be used as targets within the president’s inhumane immigration agenda.”
In Might, the department announced it was in search of the info as a part of President Donald Trump’s government order to acquire knowledge from state applications to assist root out fraud and waste. “For years, this program has been on autopilot, with no USDA perception into real-time knowledge,” USDA Secretary Brooke L. Rollins mentioned in an announcement on the time. “The Division is concentrated on applicable and lawful participation in SNAP, and as we speak’s request is certainly one of many steps to make sure SNAP is preserved for less than these eligible.”
USDA officers declined a request for touch upon the go well with.
The USDA didn’t point out immigration enforcement within the announcement or later notices. It’s not clear why USDA officers consider the info will assist it weed out fraud and abuse. The agency claims this system is already “one of the rigorous high quality management methods within the federal authorities.”
Immigration advocates famous that the Trump administration has used the identical argument to acquire different delicate knowledge, solely to later admit it might be utilizing the data to boost its deportation operations. Trump administration officers, for instance, initially claimed they had been in search of state Medicaid knowledge to struggle fraud. Final week, a prime immigration official conceded they might be using that very same data to find immigrants.
Company officers have threatened to withhold SNAP funding if states fail to adjust to their demand for knowledge.
Whereas immigrants with out authorized standing are ineligible to obtain SNAP advantages, they’ll apply on behalf of their youngsters who’re U.S. residents or those that are a part of a mixed-status family.
Below this system, previously often called meals stamps, the federal authorities pays for 100% of the meals advantages, however the states assist cowl the executive prices. States are additionally liable for figuring out whether or not people are eligible for advantages and for issuing these advantages to enrollees.
Immigration and knowledge privateness advocates expressed alarm on the Trump administration’s efforts to acquire delicate SNAP knowledge maintained by states.
“The administration has all however informed us that their intention is to comb this knowledge and use it for illegal functions that embrace immigration enforcement,” mentioned Madeline Wiseman, an legal professional with the Nationwide Pupil Authorized Protection Community, which filed a lawsuit in Might with privateness and starvation reduction teams which can be additionally difficult USDA’s efforts for SNAP knowledge.
—-
Contact the AP’s international investigative group at Investigative@ap.org or https://www.ap.org/tips/.
Copyright 2025 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials might not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.
