TRAVERSE CITY, Mich. – Some consider the Democratic Social gathering’s subsequent savior resides right here, huddled with household, within the relative obscurity of a small metropolis on the shores of Lake Michigan.
Pete Buttigieg has but to resolve if that is a duty he needs.
For now, Buttigieg, the 43-year-old former U.S. transportation secretary, is discussing his future with celebration officers, labor leaders and high strategists. He should resolve quickly whether or not he needs to return to the nationwide highlight as a candidate in Michigan’s U.S. Senate race or step apart to as a substitute search a a lot greater position as his celebration’s subsequent presidential nominee.
Distinguished allies consider Buttigieg can not feasibly do each, whilst others increase the comparability to Barack Obama, who was elected president simply 4 years after turning into a U.S. senator.
“I don’t assume you may run for Senate in 2026 and run for president in 2028 … I might assume that might be very, very arduous,” mentioned Obama’s former chief strategist David Axelrod, who met briefly with Buttigieg final week forward of a joint look on the College of Chicago.
The Democratic Social gathering could also be hurting extra at this second than it was 20 years in the past, when voters turned to that first-term senator from Illinois over extra established candidates to steer their comeback from the Bush years. Certainly, Democrats, demoralized and afraid, are crying out for robust new management with President Donald Trump and his allies, notably Elon Musk, racing to transform Washington whereas gutting key federal companies.
Buttigieg has the instruments to steer his celebration on a nationwide scale if he needs. Greater than 4 years after the little-known mayor outperformed far more experienced Democrats within the Iowa presidential caucuses, he stays one of many celebration’s finest communicators, boasting a large social media following, a nationwide donor community and a Midwestern allure he shows in Fox Information Channel interviews and smaller settings alike.
Greater than something, allies say, Buttigieg’s resolution shall be guided by the influence on his younger household at a troublesome cultural second in Trump’s America. The Republican president has targeted LGBTQ+ initiatives and inclusion applications. Buttigieg is the brazenly homosexual father of 3-year-old twins.
Axelrod complimented Buttigieg as “probably the most gifted individuals within the celebration.”
“He can be a frontline candidate in any race that he ran,” Axelrod mentioned.
Life in ‘the Cherry Capital of the World’
Buttigieg has lowered his profile since leaving the Biden administration final month.
He hasn’t completed any media interviews. He declined to talk to The Related Press for this story. And he has challenged Trump solely with a handful of social media posts, notably pushing back on the Republican president’s blaming of diversity hiring for the lethal midair collision at Ronald Reagan Washington Nationwide Airport.
However based mostly on the response, Democrats like what he has to say. His posts on X often garner tens of millions of views. And simply over per week after becoming a member of the newer social media platform Bluesky, he has shortly turn out to be one among its most-followed Democrats.
Buttigieg, a former mayor of South Bend, Indiana, has been a extra seen presence round his new dwelling of Traverse Metropolis, a lakeside resort city that calls itself “the Cherry Capital of the World.” His husband, Chasten Buttigieg, grew up in Traverse Metropolis.
“Chasten truly was a speaker at our final Obama dinner; he sat at my desk,” mentioned Lauren Flynn, an area county commissioner. “I all the time get textual content messages from of us saying, ‘Oh, my gosh, I noticed Pete buying downtown or working by the bay.’”
It’s a lot the identical on the native espresso store, Larger Grounds Buying and selling Co., which contains a pleasure flag out entrance and progressive messages on the partitions. One barista described the store as a low-profile spot the place most prospects don’t disturb the city’s highest-profile resident.
“He’s been coming in additional often,” barista Sydney Corridor mentioned not too long ago, noting she’d served Buttigieg and his husband earlier that day.
The espresso store could also be a welcoming atmosphere, however some warn of security considerations for members of the LGBTQ+ group and different distinguished Democrats within the present political atmosphere.
Aaron Wright, president of the Traverse Metropolis-based Up North Pleasure, praised Buttigieg and his household for “sacrificing their bodily security for the betterment of their native space, the state and society.” He famous Traverse Metropolis is simply 20 minutes from the place members of an area militia plotted to kidnap Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer.
“That’s the No. 1 factor that I might think about they’re contemplating is the bodily security of being the place they’re, because the those that they’re, as a result of individuals are consuming out of the firehose of misinformation and disinformation,” Wright mentioned. “Malignant teams that need to see individuals like me undergo.”
Wright’s husband, Trenton Lee, chair of the native Democratic Social gathering, mentioned his political opponents in native campaigns typically concentrate on his sexuality relatively than insurance policies.
“Pete provides that problem to the opposite aspect, the place in the event you took out his sexual orientation, the way in which he’s capable of articulate points after which truly work on them, he’s a shoo-in for no matter he runs for,” Lee mentioned. “It forces them to be like, ‘The one difficulty I’ve is that he’s homosexual.’”
Buttigieg is already going through allegations from some critics that he moved to the state solely to assist his political profession.
“It’s not simply that he carpet-bagged to Michigan a number of years in the past after being the mayor of South Bend. It’s that he did it in probably the most unrelatable enclave in the whole state,” mentioned Jason Roe, a Republican strategist and former government director of the state celebration.
Traverse Metropolis, Roe mentioned, is an “elite bubble” that solely “underscores an elitism that was one of many issues within the Democratic Social gathering.” Roe added that he’ll be stunned if Buttigieg enters the race, “as a result of if he runs and loses, he might be completed.”
A plum alternative in a key state
There could also be no higher staging floor for an formidable Democrat in 2025 than Michigan.
Democratic Sen. Gary Peters’ unexpected retirement created a uncommon Senate emptiness forward of subsequent yr’s midterms. A Republican hasn’t been elected to the U.S. Senate in Michigan this century, though Mike Rogers got here inside lower than 1 share level final fall and is planning to run once more.
Michigan additionally provides a house state benefit to any potential presidential candidate in 2028. The state is anticipated to host one of many nation’s opening presidential primaries. And within the basic election, Michigan shall be a premier swing state.
Buttigieg is leaning on highly effective allies to assist make his resolution.
Longtime Michigan Sen. Debbie Stabenow, who retired in January and considers Buttigieg a detailed good friend, attended his twins’ celebration and visited him at dwelling not too long ago. She mentioned she would not count on to endorse within the Senate major, however she informed him immediately he’d be a “very robust” candidate.
“If he introduced now, he’d be the front-runner,” Stabenow informed the AP. “He’s a Midwesterner, and he talks like a Midwesterner. He’s any person I feel individuals actually relate to.”
Stabenow mentioned she dares Buttigieg’s opponents to attempt to use his restricted time in Michigan as a political weapon.
“We’ve 1000’s of those that marry into Michigan yearly,” Stabenow mentioned. “We’ve a fantastic (former) governor who was born in Canada. If that’s the perfect they’ve obtained, nice.”
Buttigieg has not too long ago spoken with labor leaders throughout Michigan and met with Whitmer and state Sen. Mallory McMorrow, a Democrat expected to enter the Senate race quickly. Veteran Democratic strategist Lis Smith, a key adviser on Buttigieg’s 2020 presidential marketing campaign and a detailed ally, has additionally labored with McMorrow prior to now.
Exploring his attraction past Michigan
However Buttigieg can also be wanting past Michigan.
Former Rep. Annie Kuster, D-N.H., who left Congress in January, mentioned she speaks to Buttigieg semi-regularly and not too long ago inspired him to run for the Senate. Like different Buttigieg allies, she mentioned his younger household stays his chief concern as he navigates his choices.
“He’s vastly gifted,” Kuster mentioned. “And he has an incredible capability to speak — and talk with the very those that we’re lacking: the center of the nation, small cities.”
Whether or not he runs for the Senate or not, Kuster mentioned, there are many New Hampshire Democrats who’d welcome him again to the state’s high-profile presidential major in 2028. Buttigieg completed second in New Hampshire throughout his underdog 2020 presidential bid.
Kuster pointed to Obama for instance of somebody who ran for the Senate after which president a number of years later.
“These are all the issues he and his crew are navigating,” Kuster mentioned. “He clearly has a ton of decisions.”
___
Peoples reported from New York.
Copyright 2025 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials will not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.
