MEXICO CITY – Mexico held its first-ever judicial elections Sunday, stirring controversy and sowing confusion amongst voters who struggled to know a course of set to transform the country’s court system.
Polls closed and ballot staff started counting coloured ballots Sunday evening with the query hanging within the air of what is going to turn into of Mexico’s judiciary, the reply to which can solely emerge within the coming days as outcomes roll in.
Mexico’s electoral authority introduced late within the evening that 13% of Mexico’s 100 million voters solid ballots on the polls, lagging far behind the 60% turnout only a 12 months earlier than through the nation’s presidential election.
Nonetheless, Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum known as the voting “a whole success.”
“Mexico is probably the most democratic nation on the earth,” she added.
Specialists warned of startling low turnout within the lead as much as the historic elections because of the mindboggling array of unfamiliar selections and the novelty of voting for judges. Specialists say these elements might throw into query the legitimacy of the election, which has confronted months of fierce scrutiny.
Sheinbaum, a member of Mexico’s ruling occasion, Morena, rejected the criticisms and insisted the election would solely solely make Mexico extra democratic and root out corruption in a system that most individuals within the nation consider is damaged.
“Whoever says that there’s authoritarianism in Mexico is mendacity,” she mentioned. “Mexico is a rustic that’s solely changing into extra free, simply and democratic as a result of that’s the will of the individuals.”
Whereas some voters mentioned they felt pushed to vote in an election they felt would decide the destiny of the nation’s democracy, many extra expressed a deep sense of apathy, citing disillusionment because of many years of corruption and lack of primary details about the vote.
“I am not (in voting). Events and their messages — they arrive they usually go. It is all the identical,” mentioned Raul Bernal, a 50-year-old manufacturing facility employee in downtown Mexico Metropolis strolling is canine.
A historic vote
Even with out the ultimate tally, the outcomes of the vote are set to remodel Mexico’s judiciary. Morena overhauled the court system late final 12 months, fueling protests and criticism that the reform is an try by these in energy to grab on their political reputation to achieve management of the department of presidency till now out of their attain.
“It is an effort to manage the court docket system, which has been a type of thorn within the facet” of these in energy, mentioned Laurence Patin, director of the authorized group Juicio Justo in Mexico. “Nevertheless it’s a counter-balance, which exists in each wholesome democracy.”
As an alternative of judges being appointed on a system of advantage and expertise, Mexican voters have solid ballots to decide on between some 7,700 candidates vying for more than 2,600 judicial positions.
Mexicans head to the polls
Among the nation’s voting facilities opened with solely a trickle of individuals and small strains forming all through the day.
Esteban Hernández, a 31-year-old veterinary scholar, mentioned he didn’t agree with electing judges and doesn’t help Morena, however got here to vote as a result of “since there isn’t a lot participation, my vote will depend extra.”
He had studied the candidates on a web site itemizing their {qualifications} and determined to choose those that had doctorates. Different critics mentioned they solely voted for the Supreme Court docket and different prime courts.
Francisco Torres de León, a 62-year-old retired instructor in southern Mexico, known as the method “painstaking as a result of there are too many candidates and positions that they’re going to fill.”
Sheinbaum’s predecessor and political mentor, former President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, who had pushed by means of the judicial reform however remained out of the general public eye since leaving workplace final 12 months, voted in Chiapas close to his ranch.
“I needed to take part on this historic election,” he mentioned. “By no means within the historical past of our nation … have the individuals determined and had the appropriate to elect judges.”
Democratic considerations
The method has raised considerations.
Civil society organizations like Defensorxs have raised purple flags a few vary of candidates operating for election, together with attorneys who represented a few of Mexico’s most feared cartel leaders and native officers who have been pressured to resign from their positions because of corruption scandals.
Additionally amongst these placing themselves ahead are ex-convicts imprisoned for years for drug trafficking to the USA and a slate of candidates with ties to a non secular group whose non secular chief is behind bars in California after pleading responsible to sexually abusing minors.
Others like Martha Tamayo, a lawyer and former congresswoman from conflict-ravaged Sinaloa, solid doubt on projections that the election may hand much more energy over to criminals and felony teams, just because they have already got a robust management over courts.
“The affect of felony teams already exists,” she mentioned. “The cartels go along with the judges (bribe them) whether or not they’re elected or not.”
‘You need to begin with one thing’
The general public has been tormented by confusion over a voting course of that Patin warned has been unexpectedly thrown collectively. Voters usually have to select from greater than 100 candidates who are usually not permitted to obviously voice their occasion affiliation or perform widespread campaigning.
Because of this, many Mexicans mentioned they have been going into the vote blind, although others voting Sunday famous they supported the method regardless of the confusion.
Mexico’s electoral authority has investigated voter guides being handed out throughout the nation, in what critics say is a blatant transfer by political events to stack the vote of their favor.
“Political events weren’t simply going to take a seat with their arms crossed,” Patin mentioned.
Whereas nonetheless not sure if his vote would enhance entry to justice for a lot of Mexicans, 61-year-old actor Manuel José Contreras defended the election, Sheinbaum and her occasion. He solid his poll with a tone of hope.
“The reform has its issues however we would have liked an pressing change,” he mentioned. “You need to begin with one thing.”
___
AP journalists in Mexico Edgar H. Clemente in Tapachula, Alba Aléman in Xalapa and Fernando Llano in Mexico Metropolis contributed to this report.
Copyright 2025 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials is probably not printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.
