PARK CITY, Utah – After a half-century of public silence, a contract photographer from Vietnam has asserted he took one of the vital famend and impactful photographs of the twentieth century — the picture of a unadorned woman fleeing a napalm assault in South Vietnam that has lengthy been credited to a workers photographer from The Related Press.
Nguyen Thanh Nghe claimed authorship of the Pulitzer Prize-winning “napalm girl” photograph within the new documentary “The Stringer” and on the sidelines of its premiere Saturday night time on the Sundance Film Festival in Park Metropolis, Utah.
The AP performed its personal investigation and stated it has no purpose to conclude that anybody apart from the long-credited photographer, Nick Ut, made the image. The information company stated it was “stunned and upset” that filmmakers portrayed it as having reviewed the movie’s supplies and being dismissive. The AP stated it noticed the movie for the primary time at Sundance.
Nghe joined the filmmakers for the post-screening Q&A the place he stated, by way of a translator, “I took the photograph.” The viewers cheered enthusiastically. He didn’t say why he waited so lengthy to make the declare.
The AP stated it was calling on the filmmakers to launch their contributors from non-disclosure agreements for the movie, together with Nghe. It additionally known as on the filmmakers to share a visible evaluation they commissioned — and the movie itself. “We can’t state extra clearly that The Related Press is barely within the details and a truthful historical past of this iconic photograph,” the company stated.
Investigating a picture captured within the fog of conflict
Nguyen says he took the enduring photograph of Kim Phuc on June 8, 1972. Nghe stated he went to the city of Trang Bang that day as a driver for an NBC information crew and captured the picture of Phuc operating down the road, crying and bare with arms outstretched. He stated he bought his picture to the AP for $20, they usually gave him a print of the photograph that his spouse later destroyed.
Representatives for the AP, who noticed the movie for the primary time Saturday on the premiere, are contesting the movie’s implication that the corporate reviewed their findings and dismissed them.
“As not too long ago as December, we reiterated our request to see the filmmakers’ full supplies and they didn’t reply, nor did they embody AP’s full response within the movie,” Lauren Easton, an AP spokesperson, stated Sunday. “We have been stunned and upset that the movie portrayed AP as having reviewed the movie’s supplies and being dismissive of the allegations, which is totally false.”
The movie’s investigation was led by husband-and-wife workforce of Gary Knight, founding father of the VII Basis, and producer Fiona Turner. Bao Nguyen, a Vietnamese American filmmaker, directed.
“I’m not a journalist by any stretch of the creativeness,” Nguyen stated. “I had a wholesome skepticism, as I feel anybody would, going towards a 53-year-old fact. … However as a storyteller and a filmmaker, I assumed it was my each or my accountability and my privilege to have the ability to uplift the story of people like Nghe.”
AP investigated independently
Earlier than having seen the movie, the AP performed its own investigation over six months and concluded it had “no purpose to consider anybody apart from Ut took the photograph.” Now, the AP is asking on the filmmakers to carry the non-disclosure agreements they positioned on their topics to permit the corporate to research extra totally.
“AP stands able to overview any and all proof and new details about this photograph,” Easton stated.
Knight and Turner met with AP in London final June concerning the allegations. Based on the AP, filmmakers requested the information group signal a non-disclosure settlement earlier than they offered their proof. AP wouldn’t. The movie means that proof was introduced to the AP, which the AP says just isn’t true.
A major supply within the movie is Carl Robinson, then an AP photograph editor in Saigon, who was overruled in his judgment to not use the image by Horst Faas, AP’s Saigon chief of photographs. Robinson says within the movie that Faas instructed him to “make it workers” and credit score Ut for the photograph. Each Faas and Yuichi “Jackson” Ishizaki, who developed the movie, are useless. Robinson, 81, was dismissed by the AP in 1978.
On Saturday, a Sundance Institute moderator requested why he wished to return ahead with the allegations now. “I didn’t need to die earlier than this story got here out,” Robinson advised the viewers after the screening. “I wished to search out (Nghe) and apologize.”
A wide range of witnesses interviewed by AP, together with famend correspondents corresponding to Fox Butterfield and Peter Arnett and the photograph’s topic herself, Phuc, say they’re sure Ut took the photograph.
The documentary included forensics of the scene
Robinson was one such particular person the AP tried to talk to throughout their investigation however “have been advised we may solely achieve this underneath situations” that they stated would have prevented them from “taking swift motion if needed.”
The movie’s investigation took over two years. The journalists enlisted a French forensics workforce, INDEX, to assist decide the chance of whether or not Ut had been ready to take the photograph. The forensics workforce concluded that it was extremely unlikely that Ut may have achieved it.
Ut’s lawyer, James Hornstein, had this to say Sunday after the premiere: “Sooner or later, we are going to proceed to proper this improper in a courtroom the place Nick Ut’s repute shall be vindicated.”
Knight referenced AP’s investigation Saturday, telling the viewers that the corporate’s assertion is offered on-line. “They stated they’re open at all times to analyzing the reality. And I feel it was a really affordable factor to say,” Knight stated. “Our story is right here and it’s right here for you all to see.”
He added: “Issues occur within the subject within the warmth of the second. … We’re all stronger if we study ourselves, ask powerful questions, and we’re open and sincere about what goes on in our occupation. Now greater than ever, I might argue.”
“The Stringer” doesn’t but have distribution plans.
___
For extra protection of the 2025 Sundance Movie Competition, go to: https://apnews.com/hub/sundance-film-festival
Copyright 2025 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials is probably not revealed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.
