GLOUCESTER POINT, Va. – Stepping onto an outdated picket duck blind in the course of the York River, Bryan Watts appears down at a circle of sticks and pine cones on the weathered, guano-spattered platform. It’s a failed osprey nest, taken over by diving terns.
“The birds by no means laid right here this yr,” stated Watts, close to the mouth of Virginia’s Chesapeake Bay. “And that is a sample we have been seeing these final couple of years.”
Watts has a extra intimate relationship with ospreys than most individuals have with a hen — he has climbed to their nests to free them from plastic baggage, fed them by hand and monitored their eggs with telescopic mirrors.
The fish-eating raptor identified for gymnastic dives and whistle-like chirps is an American conservation success story. After pesticides and different hazards practically eradicated the species from a lot of the nation, the hawk-like hen rebounded after the banning of DDT in 1972 and now numbers within the hundreds within the U.S.
However Watts has documented an alarming development. The birds, which breed in lots of elements of the U.S., are failing to efficiently fledge sufficient chicks round their key inhabitants heart of the Chesapeake Bay. The longtime biologist blames the decline of menhaden, a small education fish important to the osprey food plan. With out menhaden to eat, chicks are ravenous and dying in nests, Watts stated.
Osprey are an environmental indicator
Watts’s declare has put him and environmental teams at odds with the fishing trade, commerce unions and generally authorities regulators. Menhaden is effective for fish oil, fish meal and agricultural meals in addition to bait.
U.S. fishermen have caught at the very least 1.1 billion kilos of menhaden yearly since 1951. Members of the trade tout its sustainability and stated the decline in osprey could don’t have anything to do with fishing.
However with out assist, the osprey inhabitants may tumble to ranges not seen for the reason that darkish days of DDT, stated Watts, director of the Middle for Conservation Biology at The School of William & Mary in Williamsburg, Virginia.
“The osprey are yelling fairly loudly that, hey, there’s not sufficient menhaden for us to breed efficiently,” Watts stated. “And we needs to be listening to them to be extra knowledgeable absolutely on the fisheries aspect, and we should always take precaution on the fisheries administration aspect. However that hasn’t gained the day at this level.”
Decline linked to menhaden in research
Watts, who has studied osprey on the Chesapeake for many years, has backed his claims of inhabitants decline by publishing research in scientific journals. He stated it boils right down to a easy statistic — to take care of inhabitants, osprey pairs have to common 1.15 chicks per yr.
Osprey have been reproducing at that degree within the Nineteen Eighties, however right now in some areas round the principle stem of the Chesapeake, it is lower than half of that, Watts stated. In significantly distressed areas, they are not even reproducing at one-tenth that degree, he stated. And the decline in obtainable menhaden matches the areas of nesting failure, Watts stated.
Additionally known as pogies or bunkers, the oily menhaden are particularly necessary for younger birds as a result of they’re extra nutritious than different fish within the sea. Osprey “reproductive efficiency is inextricably linked to the provision and abundance” of menhaden, Watts wrote in a 2023 study revealed in Frontiers in Marine Science.
Conservationists have been involved for years, saying too many menhaden have been eliminated to take care of their essential position within the ocean meals chain. Historian H. Bruce Franklin went as far as to title his 2007 ebook on menhaden “The Most Necessary Fish In The Sea.”
Fishing trade pushes again
Menhaden assist maintain one of many world’s largest fisheries, price greater than $200 million on the docks in 2023. Used as bait, the fish are important for invaluable business targets comparable to Maine lobster. They’re additionally beloved by sportfishermen.
The fashionable trade is dominated by Omega Protein, a Reedville, Virginia, firm that may be a subsidiary of Canadian aquaculture large Cooke. The corporate pushed again at the concept that fishing is the reason for osprey decline, though it did acknowledge that fewer menhaden are displaying up in some elements of the bay.
Federal information present osprey breeding is in decline in lots of elements of the nation, together with the place menhaden just isn’t harvested in any respect, stated Ben Landry, an Omega spokesperson. Local weather change, air pollution and improvement may very well be taking part in a task, stated Landry and others with the corporate.
Blaming fishing “simply reeks of environmental particular curiosity teams having an affect over the method,” Landry stated.
New guidelines may very well be on the way in which
The menhaden fishery is managed by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Fee, an interstate physique that crafts guidelines and units fishing quotas. Prompted by questions on ospreys, it created a piece group to handle precautionary administration of the species within the Chesapeake Bay.
In April, this group proposed a number of potential administration approaches, together with seasonal closures, restrictions on quotas or days at sea, and limitations on sorts of fishing gear. The method of making new guidelines may start this summer season, stated James Boyle, fishery administration plan coordinator with the fee.
The osprey inhabitants has certainly proven declines in some areas since 2012, nevertheless it’s necessary to recollect the hen’s inhabitants is way bigger than it was earlier than DDT was banned, Boyle stated.
“There are huge will increase in osprey inhabitants for the reason that DDT period,” Boyle stated, citing federal information displaying a six-fold enhance in osprey populations alongside the Atlantic Coast for the reason that Sixties.
Environmentalists says hen’s decline may worsen
To a variety of environmental teams, any decline is an excessive amount of. This irritates some labor leaders who fear about shedding extra jobs because the fishing trade declines.
Kenny Pinkard, retired vice chairman of UFCW Native 400’s govt board and a longtime Virginia fishermen, stated he feels the trade is being scapegoated.
“There are some individuals who simply do not need to see us in enterprise in any respect,” he stated.
However Chris Moore, Virginia govt director for Chesapeake Bay Basis, stated the nation dangers shedding an iconic hen if no motion is taken. He stated Watts’s research present that the osprey will fail with out entry to menhaden.
“Osprey have been successful story,” Moore stated. “We’re in a scenario the place they are not changing their numbers. We’ll really be in a scenario the place we’re in a steep decline.”
___
Whittle reported from Portland, Maine.
___ This story was supported by funding from the Walton Household Basis. The AP is solely accountable for all content material.
Copyright 2025 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials might not be revealed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.
